Internal, External and Why it is ALWAYS Recommended
Before we begin on the titled subject understand that this article will focus on why we at General Air Products recommend a motor starter for overload protection with every unit. If you would like to know more about what a motor starter is please view our motor starters. You can also see what happens to a motor that is not protected with a motor starter by clicking here.
Troubleshooting Air Compressor Motors
Overload protection for motors goes by many names, they all mean the same thing. Here are a few of those terms:
- Magnetic Line Starter
- Line Starter
- Overload protection
- Motor Starter
- External Overload Protection
- Manual Overload Protection
- Internal Overload Protection
You can also count on seeing these terms used interchangeably. This causes a lot of confusion in the field, hopefully the list will help you understand that they are all the same thing.
Now, to the actual article!
As stated above, we recommend an external motor starters for overload protection to be installed with every one of our units even though some of our units have overload protection built into the motors (internal overload protection). While there is some redundancy we have a very specific reason we make this recommendation.
Let’s step back a minute first to address the larger question of “Is a motor starter required on every dry pipe system air compressor?” The answer is yes. The code that requires overload protection for dry pipe system air compressors can be found in article 430 of NFPA 70 (2008 edition) well as the National Electrical Code.
Now that we have established the requirement for overload protection you should understand the difference between the two types of overload protection offered from General Air Products – internal overload protection at the motor and external overload protection via the motor or line starter.
(For a breakdown of which of our compressors come with internal overload protection and a guide for choosing the right overload protection for the compressor model you are using, see Motor Overload Protection Selection Sheet)
All of our single phase oil less air compressors and our single phase lubricated air compressors below 1.5 HP have internal overload protection at the motor. In these cases an external motor starter is not required as internal is sufficient to satisfy code. However we still recommend using the external overload protection in these instances.
Both internal and external motor overload protection work the same way. When the motor starter senses an electrical problem the overloads (which are coils located within the motor starter) heat up and break the electrical connection to the motor, thereby protecting the air compressor from the type of damage shown in the picture below.
Internal Overload Protection
In the case of internal overload protection when the overloads cool off the motor in the air compressor will restart automatically. If the voltage issue that caused the original shut down is still present the motor will be shut down again. This constant starting and stopping of the motor will continue until the problem is addressed or the air compressor’s motor dies an untimely death. The chances of the problem being addressed are slim as the only alarm that will go off will be the low air alarm and that will not occur until the compressor is dead (in most instances). So even while the internal overload works properly you may never know about the problem until the compressor motor is burnt.
External Overload Protection
External overload protection addresses this issue with a manual restart button (the blue button on the box shown in the picture above). You see when there is an electrical issue with an air compressor where external overload protection is employed the compressor will not restart when the overload contacts cool as it does in the internal overload protection. In fact the compressor will not restart at all until the manual reset button is pressed - this is the primary and most important difference in the function of internal versus external motor overload protection. With external overload protection, at the time of the electrical issue, the compressor will stop and the issue will have to be addressed by a fire protection professional.
This is why we recommend external overload protection (or an external motor starter) with each of our air compressors in a dry pipe sprinkler system – the problem must be addressed and the life of the air compressor will be preserved!